When children miss a vaccination, they assume more risk of not only severe illness, but also lifelong complications. They also risk more than themselves, affecting herd immunity and compromising more vulnerable community members, including young children, older adults, and those with weakened immune systems.

The reasons behind insufficient vaccination rates are much more complicated than knowing (or not knowing) statistics and best practices. To better understand which barriers are preventing higher vaccination rates in California, Blue Shield of California assembled experts for a webinar focused on “Strengthening Immunization Reporting, Smarter Data, Better Outcomes.” The webinar included clinical, quality improvement, and public health perspectives on how California can strengthen the infrastructure that helps children get vaccinated on time. The panelists included:

  • Eric Ball, MD, an Orange County primary care pediatrician, chair of the American Academy of Pediatrics in California, and member of the national AAP board of directors. Dr. Ball also co-chairs the data and implementation working group of the vaccine coalition discussed during the webinar.
  • Kerry Donohue, senior program manager at the California Quality Collaborative (CQC), who leads its immunization improvement work, including a six-month pilot with Blue Shield of California involving five pediatric practice sites.
  • Michael Powell, chief of the Registry and Assessment Section within the California Department of Public Health’s Immunization Branch, whose work includes helping organizations submit and improve immunization data.

Joe Castiglione, associate director of strategy, partnerships, and policy at Blue Shield of California, moderated the discussion.

 

Understanding why children fall behind

During the 2025-2026 school year, vaccination coverage among kindergartners in the United States decreased for all reported vaccines compared to the prior year.

Vaccine hesitancy is an important challenge, but the panelists urged participants to look closely at access and clinical operations as well. Families may miss an appointment, struggle to find an available clinician, or leave a visit without scheduling the next dose. Parents may not realize their child has fallen behind.

Missing one dose in a series may reflect a missed opportunity rather than a decision against vaccination. In his quality improvement work, Dr. Ball has focused on reviewing vaccination needs at every visit.

Understanding the reason behind a gap helps organizations choose a response. During the webinar, Dr. Ball described comparing well-child visit claims with vaccination records to explore whether children were missing care altogether or attending visits without receiving vaccines. He emphasized that this is an imperfect proxy: the data can guide further investigation, but it cannot establish a family’s reasons on its own.

Recommended action: Assess appointment access: examine vaccine-only visits, scheduling availability, and other barriers that can prevent families from returning. Make follow-up part of the current encounter rather than relying on families to remember later.

 

Giving practices information early enough to act

For a busy practice, a list labeling children as up to date or overdue offers limited direction. Teams need to know which child needs attention, which vaccine and dose are missing, and when the next dose can be given.

Donohue emphasized the value of regularly refreshed, patient-level reports covering children throughout their first two years of life. Reports focused only on children approaching their second birthday may arrive too late to complete a series on time, due to required intervals between doses.

Organizing reports into age bands—such as birth to six months, six to 12 months, 12 to 18 months, and 18 to 24 months—can make outreach more manageable. Including prior dose dates and the next eligible vaccination date helps staff prioritize families and schedule follow-up.

In the CQC and Blue Shield pilot, access to reports covering younger children has helped practices identify missing doses and investigate discrepancies. A missing birth dose of hepatitis B may reflect a hospital record that never reached the registry or practice. Resolving that discrepancy is different from bringing a child in for a missed vaccination.

Recommended action: Review vaccination needs at every visit, not just at well-child appointments.

 

Making CAIR data more complete and usable

The California Immunization Registry (CAIR) is central to assembling vaccination histories across care settings. But its usefulness depends on the completeness and consistency of the submitted records.

Inaccurate or missing information can interfere with patient matching, leaving one child’s vaccination history split across multiple records. Changes in insurance, transfers between practices, and moves across state lines create additional challenges in piecing together a complete history.

The panelists called for consistent reporting formats and delivery schedules from health plans, along with clear feedback loops when records disagree. Health plans can help resolve attribution and reporting discrepancies; practices can flag information that does not match their records; public health and technical partners can help troubleshoot submission problems.

California’s Digital Vaccine Record offers another way to spot missing information by engaging Californians directly. Powell explained that people accessing their own or their children’s records sometimes identify absent doses, prompting follow-up with the administering provider.

Powell’s strongest recommendation was direct: “submit complete, standardized data every single time.” He also emphasized including National Drug Codes to improve the identification of vaccine products and support accurate forecasting.

Recommended action: Track what happens after outreach. Record whether a family was reached, an appointment was scheduled, a barrier was identified, or a vaccine was administered elsewhere.

 

Building stronger infrastructure together

For practices, plans, and public health partners, participation can begin with a concrete contribution: improve the completeness of submitted records, provide earlier and more usable patient lists, help families schedule needed care, or share workflow lessons with peers. Together, those changes can help California turn immunization information into timely vaccination for more children.

Work is already well underway in some sectors. Blue Shield of California is part of the Public Health for All Californians Together (PHACT) Coalition, which is designed to bring together multi-sectoral partners to provide timely, evidence-based guidelines and culturally appropriate health messaging for all Californians. The Coalition is led by CDPH, with support from Covered California and UCSF’s Collaborative for Public Health Research (CPR3). 

More recently, Blue Shield was also named a founding partner of The California Public Health Department in launching the Public Health Network Information Exchange Innovation Institute (PHNIX II). The Institute will advance practical, technology-enabled solutions to address California’s public health challenges, including disease prevention. As a founding partner, Blue Shield’s initial work will focus on closing gaps in childhood vaccination and helping more children across the state receive the care they need.

Learn more about PHINX II.